Chisholm opened the season as the Yankees' second baseman and hit the IL in early May batting .181 with a .714 OPS. However, DJ LeMahieu's return and Oswaldo Cabrera's severe ankle injury forced Chisholm back to third base, where he spent most of last season.

Yankees legend Lou Gehrig's start to the 1927 campaign places just below Judge on that same list, and he too proceeded to win MVP that year with a .373 average, 1.240 OPS and 173

If you’re Aaron Judge, you can forget about going out for a cup of coffee on the road. In fact, sightseeing in any baseball city the Yankees go through is off the table for the captain because he’s not leaving his hotel room.